CMP Forums

CMP Forums (
-   Ask CMP (
-   -   Feedback on new cases (

Hbus1300 08-07-2018 11:19 AM

Feedback on new cases
IMO the new cases and shipping cardboard both are absolute trash.

Issues with the Cardboard
-Not thick enough to protect the case at all, previous green case cardboard was a better quality.

Issues with the Case
-Latches don't stay latched in shipping

-Because of poor case design the ends of the case open allowing the muzzle to protrude out of the case during shipping

-The foam isn't thick enough to keep the rifle from moving around in the case, they know this which is evident by the extra chunks of foam they're using around the receiver and muzzle in an attempt to stabilize things

-It seems the plastic itself is mickey mouse as I had one that the muzzle broke through the case and actually protruded through the cardboard picking up a few dings in the process.

The CMP needs to do a better job protecting the rifles. The new cases might survive a trip to the range, but they're not suitable for shipping. I received some field grade rifles and was upset, I can only imagine my frustration with a nicer rifle shipped in this manner.

aimit 08-09-2018 12:58 PM

Sounds like the old heavy cardboard shipping boxes were better than this.

mrbullets 08-10-2018 01:19 AM


Originally Posted by aimit (Post 1743444)
Sounds like the old heavy cardboard shipping boxes were better than this.

Yes, they were. The new cases are flimsy.

lucky52 08-19-2018 06:13 PM

Where are they made just out of curiosity?

Redtail 08-21-2018 07:01 PM

I had a post or two removed in this thread for something ? Anyone know why ?

Smal 08-22-2018 01:16 AM


This is tiresome. That's enough of the obsessive, personal vendetta attacks, especially when you do not have, or even try to understand the facts before you post these false accusations and continue to hijack other's threads.

Do not post in this thread again.

Big_Red 08-23-2018 04:26 AM


Originally Posted by lucky52 (Post 1746362)
Where are they made just out of curiosity?

I will find out that information later today, as well as pass on the concerns posted here and in other threads.



Originally Posted by Redtail (Post 1747046)
I had a post or two removed in this thread for something ? Anyone know why ?

Nothing personal...we merely try to keep the Ask CMP threads clean of extraneous postings so that it helps the appropriate parties answer them when they are able to.
Some here, and not you, seem completely unable to grasp that concept, or comprehend forum rules.

As per your own words, " own musings" it was simply that they addressed packing/cases that had nothing to do with the OP, as well as answering lucky52's question with the wrong information.

steelap 08-23-2018 04:43 AM


Originally Posted by Big_Red (Post 1747424)
..., as well as answering lucky52's question with the wrong information.

I like the way you phrase things. :)

"Life is Good!"

ZvenoMan 08-23-2018 06:26 AM

Here is a thought:
CMP, trying to maximize operating efficiency, needs to ship rifles. They have negotiated an extremely low shipping rate, and, faced with the next part of the process, need a packing method. A foam-lined cardboard box has a fixed cost and most likely a good amount of data related to % of items damaged in transit based on CMP's use in the past. They also have used a low end plastic case enclosed in a cardboard box, like today's method, or the prior green case.
Perhaps their ONLY goal is the lowest overall shipping cost, factoring in these 3 items: Cost of shipping (and any associated lowered insurance based on this lowered cost), cost of packaging, and overall damage (which means replacement) rate.
If this method costs the least, yet a few of the plastic cases are damaged/destroyed, that seems like a win. Delivering the customer a plastic case is not the measured goal here.
So far in this and other threads I have seen examples where the shipping caused damage to the case, but I don't recall any damage to the rifle? Many people consider that a "win"; the case did as CMP wanted; took the damage while protecting the contents? And many wind up with a free, low end plastic rifle case as well. Sacrificial packaging is a thing, at least in the business world, oh, DOD, Government, whatever.
To many, the shipping cases are like coat hangers; I'm sure there are threads in the marketplace with people offering to give them away.

Nah, I'm sure they didn't put this kind of thought to shipping.....

gunny 08-23-2018 02:56 PM

Ah jus' break out the Gorilla Tape and the case will be as good as new.....

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:59 PM.