Go Back   CMP Forums > CMP Sales > Ammunition
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read

Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 10-09-2011, 08:29 PM
jabbo jabbo is offline
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 425

Originally Posted by mosin10 View Post
It is insane to put water in your barrel. Just clean with hoppes elite once and oil well. There is soo much internet hype about cleaning after corrosive ammo. There are also many more "experts" who will tell you to use windex, hot water, cold water, cooking oil, fried chicken grease, etc. For some reason it seems like a good percentage of gun guys know everything there is to know about everything.

Clean with hoppes eilite, oil the gun. Spend your time on shooting and not on cleaning. If you have a very valuable gun, you probably don't want to shoot old mil surp out of it anyway.
Hoppes Elite will take care of salt residue from ammo with corrosive primers, just as well as tap water does - but it's a bit more expensive and inconvenient since one has to purchase it rather than turning on one's water tap. Running a water-soaked brush or patch in the bore is perfectly rational as long as one runs a sufficient number of dry patches through the bore to remove the water. Oiling afterward is a good idea regardless of which method one uses.

Regarding shooting milsurp ammo or any other kind of perceived old/unreliable ammo in a very valuable firearm - if the very valuable firearm is modern (meaning that it was designed to use smokeless powder) then any smokeless powder ammo is appropriate regardless whether it's corrosive or not - provided the owner of said very valuable firearm knows what the hell he/she is doing.
Reply With Quote
Old 10-09-2011, 08:40 PM
mosin10 mosin10 is offline
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 88

Shooting is an expensive sport. From ammo to range time, to building collections. It is a costly addiction. I buy hoppes for 4.99 a bottle from Walmart. I just can't bring myself to clean any gun with water when there are better options available that wont potentially cause harm. I have heard of too many guys using these crazy scrubbing day after day techniques to clean corrosive salts. Constant excessive cleaning will damage a gun way more than corrosive ammo. Just my opinion. It has worked for me.
Reply With Quote
Old 10-14-2011, 08:11 AM
Parker1942 Parker1942 is offline
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Louisville, KY
Posts: 215
Default KA 73 30-06 is Corrosive Primed?

Can anyone advise if KA 73 30-06 ammo is in fact corrosive? I have a lot of it and assumed it was non-corrosive so have been shooting in my garands. Is there any reliable way to test for corrosive vs non-corrosive?

Reply With Quote
Old 10-19-2011, 12:41 PM
mattp mattp is offline
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Fair Lawn, NJ
Posts: 1,328

i'm pretty sure the KA stuff is corrosive.
Reply With Quote
Old 10-19-2011, 01:40 PM
hammonje hammonje is offline
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Union, KY
Posts: 4,498

You need a polar solvent of which Hoppes No9 is not. You are trying to remove potassium chloride. Windex will certainly remove it and the ammonia aslo cuts copper well. Cheap, effective, and simple household cleaner. Chemistry dictates this cleaning regimen. Do what you want with your rifles, but I prefer to run a Windex patch down my bore. Takes an entire 15 seconds and provides peace of mind for my investment portfolio.
Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2011, 04:47 PM
Black Eagle Black Eagle is offline
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 73

Originally Posted by .Steve. View Post
(This post started out on the .30 Carbine forum and has marched away down the page.)

A question about corrosive ammo on the ammo forum jogged my noggin' that last weekend at a show, I saw both French and Chinese corrosive primed .30 Carbine ammo. Guys in need of money are selling basement stashes they have sat on for years. Beware. They also lie about what it is, even if they do know.

The French ammo has metric marked boxes and the Chinese ammo tries to mimic "LC 52" headstamped USGI. Both are corrosive and both will destroy the barrel and gas system and bolt and receiver of a USGI carbine unless a lot of effort is put into cleaning them. Especially the usually not dismantled gas cylinder and piston.

Please make sure you know what you are buying and using because I, personally, and me, would never fire the stuff in even my Blue Sky return Carbine. Clear enough opinion, I guess.

The following is an old poste about corrosive ammo, the hows and whys, and how to clean a rifle if you must ignore advice. Keep in mind that a cheap carbine is worth 5 or 10 Mosin-Nagnat M91/30s or Turkish Mausers.

I have no problem using surplus corrosive Russian, Bulgarian, Hungarian, or Czech corrosive 7.62x54Rmm rimmed Russian or 7.92x57mm Mauser in those rifles. And I promise mine are nice ones. But I clean them as noted below to keep them nice.

What are the Mosins and Mausers good for you might ask with corrosive ammo? When all else fails to cure the need for speed, blast, and recoil, moving mud and busting rocks at 300 or 400 yards is good fun. Pick up the brass (I lied, its steel) and trash it. You are done with the ammo then. No reloading, just feed'em, work the bolt, and repeat for 40 or 50 rounds and you know you went shooting.

The payback is in the cleaning of the rifle after using corrosive ammo. Keep in mind, there is no such thing as a little corrosive.

Any hoo, the info below is long, boring, and accurate.

This note except for this paragraph is a saved post concerning cleaning firearms fired with corrosive primed ammunition. To it I would add that the Army tried one batch of "test" corrosive ammo just to see what would happen with a carbine. The result was bad as the gas system does not lend itself to a proper cleaning every time corrosive ammo is fired. If you must use French or Chineese corrosively primed ammo, I hope you have a good cleaning plan.

Copy/Pasted Text of Post:

The scope of the problem was best addressed by an American Rifleman article entitled "Is There Salt In Your Gun Barrel?" at page 36 October 1971. Excerpted is the following to make the point:

"...Various solvents were brought out as bore cleaning solvents. Their success was quite limited. They left the bore apparently clean, but usually it rusted later and required cleaning again, often several times. That is still the consequence of cleaning with only the usual "powder solvent" after firing ammunition of the corrosive type."

"...When the primer is fired, the oxygen of this compound is used, leaving potassium cloride...This is akin to table salt and sea salt, and like them will rust iron and steel in the presence of water. There is water in the air under most conditions, and the steel bore surface, covered with wet salt, rusts.....The potassium cloride can pull water through heavy coatings of grease, so oiling or greasing a fouled bore does not protect it."

"...Trials have shown that the rusting does not occur in very low atmospheric humidities. But the potassium cloride remains unaffected until the humidity rises again for rusting to start or restart. This has been known to happen after the lapse of years."

"...Water is the best solvent of potassium cloride. Soap or sal soda (soda ash, washing soda) in the water cuts the stickiness of the foulding and hot water heats the barrel and makes drying it easier. A bronze bore brush breaks up the fouling and makes the cleaning easier and more effective. Stick the gun muzzle into a container of hot soap suds and pump the bore full several times with a bronze brush on the cleaning rod. If the bore cannot be cleaned from the breech, lay the arm flat to avoid getting water into the breech mechanism, and clean the bore with wet brush and patches. Dry the bore, and oil or grease it for preservation."

"Government bore cleaner is required by rigorous test to clean bores effectively after corrosive ammunition firing."

"Some questions remain."

"Will water cleaning prevent all damage? In general, no. Military experience even in peacetime showed that continued firing of corrosive-primed ammunition results in slow roughening of the bore. It seems to have been imposible in practice to clean the bore soon enough and well enough after every firing. The result was a prolonged annoyance, continual attention being necessary and the rifle bores eventually becoming more or less pitted though mostly still serviceable. Some of these were ruined, and many in civilian use have been damaged. But most damage can be prevented."

"Will water cleaning remove metal (jacket" fouling? No....."

Corrosive Ammo Cleaning Methods Discussion

The first thing to understand is that nothing neutralizes a salt. It is the end product of chemical reactions.

The best idea is to assume that most military surplus ammo, 7.62x54mmR, 8x57mm, .303 British, 7.62x39mm is corrosive.

Most NON United States milsurp ammo through at least 1980 is corrosive around the world.

Except for non-corrosive (semi-commercial by Norinco) Chineese 7.62x39mmn beginning around 1990, most military 7.62x39mm is corrosive whenever made. Recently made Russian commercial is not corrosive but that is now so expensive it is gone from most markets.

NATO headspamped 7.62x51mm and 5.56mm is non corrosive.

Most .30 Carbine is non corrosive, but there are French and Chineese look a likes that are corrosive. The Chineese is headstamped LC52, but the boxes are identifiable. Do not use that garbage. The French is corrosive. The Chineese is Berdan primed and my rule is that Berdan primed is always corrosive unless recently made. Some shooters are insisting some of the Chineese LC52 is non corrosive because it has not rusted their Carbines. More power to them. The garbage don't go into mine.

The flushing concept:

Once the concept of flushing away potassium chlorate primer residue is understood for being exactly that, flushing out and wiping off, then some evaluation of methods that will prove useful can be done.

Keep in mind there is the KCL salt residue itself and the accompanying problems of powder fouling and of copper fouling. Both of the extra problems help trap the corrosive salts.

Point 1: The potassium salts created by the primers are the end product of chemical reactions. They are not broken down and are not neutralized. That is why salt goes to the sea and stays there. Salts can be dissolved but do not chemically change.

Point 2: Water or water containing products dissolve potassium salts. Next to nothing else does. The potassium salts are not "neutralized", but simply dissolved for flushing out of the bore or for wiping off of the metal outside.

Point 3: Most modern bore cleaners contain no water and do a poor job of preparing potassium salts for flushing out. Modern bore cleaners can help dissolve powder fouling that helps release the salts to flush out. A different but related idea.

Point 4. Something to dissolve the potassium salts and something to break up powder/copper fouling works well in tandem to get the steel cleaned thoroughly.

Point 5. The now clean bore still has to be protected with an oil to prevent rusting.

For beginners, the most important thing is that they do not rely on modern bore cleaners for corrosive ammo. What they need to keep in mind is that Hoppe's #9 now has no, none, zero, nada, neutralization of corrosive potassium chloride salt capability. Whatever argueable ability it might have had years ago when the bottles were labeled as helpful and stunk to high heaven, it currently has no help at all in the mild smelling kind.

The actual action of Hoppe's is to partially wash out stuff from the barrel and break up powder fouling. Flushing out is different than chemical neutralization. With potassium salts, you can dissolve it, but it does not change form. Hoppe's without water does not dissolve it. It just partially flushes it out. Relying on Hoppe's is relying on very little help. Once cleaned Hoppe's cleaned bores usually rust a few weeks or months later.

USGI bore cleaner will dissolve and flush out corrosive salts in any of its many flavors and colors of performance based mixtures. The fluids were performance spec based items rather than a specific formula. The USGI bore cleaners are water based, dissolve corrosive salts, have a mild metal jacket fouling remover, and leave a water soluable oil in the bore when the water content dries out. You can actually watch the white milky kind dry and turn to a clear oil.

The result is a temporary coating of water soluble oil on the bore that offers some protection until a better oil can be used. Depending on which USGI bore cleaner is used, there is some very mild copper removal. The white milky kind produces a green/blue residue as it sits in the bore overnight.

Water based cleaners (Windex and such) may flush out corrosive salts fairly well, but don't actually chemically neutralize them. Windex simply dissolves the potassium cloride salts in the bore.

The ammonia in the water based solutions like Windex helps break up powder fouling releasing the trapped salts for flushing out. The ammonia also attacks copper deposits which also releases potassium salts for flushing out.

The potassium salts created by the primers are the end product of chemical reactions. As the end product chemical reaction, ammonia doesn't actually undo the KCL bonds. This is why the oceans are full of salt. It is the last product of chemical reactions and flows away with water. Windex just helps flush it out of the bore and helps dissolve it off of outside metal parts.

Windex and the various similiar water based cleaners leave nothing in the bore to protect it. There is no oil component in them of any sort.

Boiling water down a barrel is a long tested method to get rid of almost all corrosive salts because it flushes the potassium salts out of the bore very effectively. That should be followed by regular cleaning with powder fouling removers and jacket metal fouling removers and bore preservatives. Water works, expecially boiling soapy water, but in truth it is a mess because it is not just the bore that needs cleaned.

Using boiling water, cleaning the bore is easy with a short hose or tubing on a funnel, but the other parts of the rifle needing cleaned are not so easy. The entire bolt and bolt way, the trigger guard where you touch, and the muzzle all need cleaned. And lets not forget the entire gas system of a Garand.

Boiling water followed by three days cleaning with USGI bore cleaner is effective. All places corrosive salt bearing gasses can reach should be cleaned with USGI bore cleaner (outside of barrel, bolt face, bolt locking lug recesses, breech areas, and so on.) This is one reason USGI bore cleaner is so useful. You can scrub it into all sorts of places and then wipe it off without harm as it leaves a water soluable oil on the metal as the water content in the bore cleaner dries off the metal.

Boiling water also works so well partially because it expands the cracks in the steel and releases the salts from down inside the metal. Then it washes them away. It is also hot and drys the bore of liquid water.

For a one product system with the least work, USGI bore cleaner will work fine by itself. There are several different formulas and they are all water soluble oil compounds that dissolve and clean away potassium salts by flushing them out the muzzle. The white milky ones and the ones that are clearish smelling like benzene both operate the same way. They dissolve potassium chloride salt to be carried out of the bore. They also leave an oil coating as the water content evaporates off the metal. they have a mild effect on jacket fouling.

Good looking cans should be selected and the rusty, dented, leaking cans should be avoided as unknowns. Check every lid seal before buying.

It would be nice if some manufacturer marketed a modern equivalent of USGI bore cleaner. It is still being manufactured for the services as some weapons are corrosive primed in larger calibers. (As of Feb. 2010, I would guess most of that has been fired up in two wars, at least most all of the old M2 .50 Cal.)

There is a Birchwood-Casey product for cleaning blackpowder firearms but I am aware of no information concerning what it does to corrosive primer residue.

Keep in mind that corrosive salts are sufficiently hydroscopic (the ability to attract water) that they can pull water from the air right through oils and greases in the bore. Water is what causes iron alloys to rust. The oxygen in the water reacts with the iron particles forming iron oxide better known as rust. Salt attracts water causes rust. Oil and grease are not rust preventives when applied over corrosive salts.

Clean from the breech to muzzle where possible based on the firearm design. This pushes the salts out of the muzzle and away from the action system. Thoroughly clean gas systems if you must shoot the stuff in gas guns.

A Cleaning Plan That Works

My personal solution is simple and way easier than it sounds. It has never failed to protect a rifle fired with corrosive ammo:

a) Immediately after shooting, clean the bore, bolt, action and locking recess areas, muzzle areas, and other touched metal with USGI bore cleaner. Mauser's have the bolt dis-assembled because it is so easy. En fields have the head screwed off for cleaning the firing pin. Small size spiral wire brushes are dedicated to this corrosive ammo cleaning in my range kit. The kit has its own rod, brushes, bristle brushes, patches, paper towels, tooth brushes and so on to take right to the range and not mix up with "clean" stuff used for non-corrosive ammo firearms.

b) Re-clean the bore and action day two and day three with USGI bore cleaner.

c) Clean the bore with Hoppe's #9 day four and day five and day six.

d) On day six, oil all the metal parts with a normal gun oil. Reclean the inside of the bolt. The Hoppe's stays in the bore for short term storage.

e) The rifle is always racked muzzle down to drain fluids out the muzzle into a cloth until stored.

Remember, with consistent good cleaning practices, corrosive ammo does no harm. Forget once, and you ruin a bore. Without good cleaning practices, corrosive ammo will ruin a bore overnight in the worst cases.
Good info here!!! Wanted to ad this from Mark (gunplumber)

"corrosive" is salt.

Salt does not dissolve in oil.

Salt dissolves in water.

Salt dissolves better in hot water.

Soap does not dissolve salt. Soap is a surfactant. A surfactant reduces the surface tension of the water so that it is less viscous, it "flows" better and penetrates better.

Hot water evaporates faster.

I plop my guns in the utility sink and rinse with hot water. Then blow-dry with compressed air.

Everyone wants their own special formula, but the bottom line is: water. Hot water, or water + surfactant may have a marginal difference, but no oil-based product is going to help.


I got news for everyone - Hoppe's #9 has been around for over 100 years. There are Colts still inn functioning shape that a re over 100 years old. Hoppe's was cleaning out salts way before there were "non-corrosive" primers.

The question is not WHAT to clean with... but HOW WELL do you clean? clean the gas tube eVERY TIME? clean the piston face EVERY TIME? clean out the gas block and barrel to gas block air hole EVERY TIME?

I shoot well in excess of 50K rounds a year, and about 90% of that is corrosive. I DO NOT use windex or ammonia. I will use dawn dish soap if I've shot more than 5K in one sitting, but only because its faster to use a toothbrush and soap then flush with a garden hose and air compressor.

Experiences of many people says that windex will not hurt a military gun if you remove it afterward and it is cheap. Yes there are a lot of different ammonia compounds and it is present in the more expensive bore cleaners for the removal of copper. I use the hot water because I know from experience it works and is cheap. Is a little time consuming. Probably hoppes will also do by itself as will many others.

I just talked to a chemist and he said you do get ammonium chloride formed from using ammonium ions. The NH4Cl is soluble, but so is the KCl in water. The mainthing is the windex is a cleaning formulation and so may be more effective then just plain water. Ammonia is also basic which would counteract any acids that might be around. Either soapy water or windex should work fine if you make sure to remove them thoroughly and when done properly oil the gun. By the way I also clean the bolt face and on auto loading weapons the gas system and at least oil everything well like the springs, guide, etc.
Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2011, 10:27 PM
mosin10 mosin10 is offline
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 88

Bottom line. Hopped elite works very well to prevent corrosion after shooting corrosive ammo. Put your rifle in the bathtub and scrub for an hour if you want, but I can see way more damage being done. Am I the only one not buying into the windex/ bathing your gun in water after shooting it concept. Corrosive ammo is usually cheap and plentiful. I would never shoot it in an auto loading rifle. My concern in the gas system. I would shoot it all day in a bolt action. Clean it within a few days and oil it. Has anyone tried my method and had rust or corrosion? I want to hear direct experiences and not your cousins friends nephew who shot a round of corrosive and had a bucket of rust 5 hours later. Corrosive primers were used for many years and I feel confident shooting the ammo from bolt actions and cheap pistols (tokarev stockpile)
Reply With Quote
Old 01-18-2012, 09:22 AM
.Steve. .Steve. is offline
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 875

Been a long time since I was here. Dial up and an ancient computer.

The only thing I would add to what is above is that copper fouling should be removed from the barrels for two reasons:

1) Most basic is that salts get trapped between the steel barrel and the copper streaks attracting water making corrosion.

2) More complicated is that the two dis-similiar metal make a battery and end up eating the steel under the copper. Galvanic corrosion is the term, I think.

I remain happy with my original cleaning suggestions. They amount to the removal of salts and then the removal of copper and powder fouling. The USGI Bore Cleaner does both. The Hoppe's #9 works on powder fouling and copper. Between them, they have kept my bores bright and shinny.

I did see recently an advertisement for a new corrosive primer specific bore cleaning solution. What it was called escapes me at the moment. Perhaps some one has seen it advertised?
Reply With Quote
Old 01-09-2013, 09:34 PM
CraZ4GunZ CraZ4GunZ is offline
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Maryland
Posts: 8

I've been using a 10% mix of Ballistol to hot water mix for over a year now. Works good. I still use a little Windex/mostly water at the range until I run out then I'll refill the bottle with the Ballistol mix. As others have said its the water that gets the salts out the rest is hype/myth/Bubba's or whatever else you want to call it.
Reply With Quote
Old 02-17-2013, 11:26 PM
.Steve. .Steve. is offline
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 875

Endless opinions. Both salts and metal fouling ruin bores. I remain happy with my advice. My bores remain bright and shinny. Round after round of 7.62x54mmR Russian and 8x57mm Mauser keep going downrange. The same cleaning system keeps them nice.
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:59 PM.